Insights

Dialing

Your ninth dial is your last good one.

A look at how one agent's dial time is spread across their book. Nearly two-thirds of last week's dials went to leads already called ten or more times, long past the point where they still convert. Here is where the time goes, and how to get it back.

Silver Bow Call Analytics
Published October 2026
Download the study (PDF)
Figure 1
Conversation rate (60s or more) by attempt number on a given lead
12.5
7.9
5.3
5.1
3.5
2.7
2.7
2.8
2.4
0.9
0.6
1.3
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10-19
20-29
30+
Attempts 1-9 convert 2.4% to 12.5%Attempts 10+ around 1% or less

This is a look at how one agent's dial time is spread across their book. The clearest pattern: a fast-growing share of calling time is going to leads they have already dialed ten, twenty, even thirty-plus times, and right now that, not the age of the leads or the size of the book, is the main thing standing between them and more pickups.

Line up conversation rate against attempt number and the shape is stark. The first attempt converts at 12.5%. By the ninth it is down to 2.4%, still a real return, just a much smaller one. After that it falls off a cliff: every attempt past the ninth converts at roughly one percent or below, and it does not recover no matter how high the count climbs. Across the full calling history, attempts one through nine are about 73% of all dials; last week they were only 36.5%.

Conversation rate by attempt number: 12.5% on the first dial, 7.9% second, 5.3% third, 5.1% fourth, 3.5% fifth, 2.7% sixth, 2.7% seventh, 2.8% eighth, 2.4% ninth. Then attempts 10 to 19 convert 0.9%, 20 to 29 convert 0.6%, and 30 or more convert 1.3%. A conversation here means a connected call of 60 seconds or more.

Where the week actually goes

In the week of September 7 to 13, 63.5% of every dial was attempt number ten or later on that lead, including 21.2% at attempt twenty or later. Only 36.5% fell inside the first nine attempts, the window where conversion is highest, and just 10.5% of the leads touched that week got a first-ever dial. The best-converting attempts are the ones being made least.

This is not a supply problem. It is a pacing problem.

The book is not too small or too stale. 98.6% of owned leads have been dialed at least once, new leads are arriving at roughly double the pace of the prior ten weeks, and 81% of fresh leads now get a first dial within seven days, up from 44% earlier in the summer. The leads are there and they are moving. The constraint is how the hours get spent once the leads are in the book.

It is not the oldest leads

The heaviest redial load is not on the oldest leads. It sits on leads roughly one week to three months old: 49% of dials on 8 to 30 day leads, and 36% on 1 to 3 month leads, are already attempt ten or later. The oldest leads, twelve months and up, carry the lightest redial load of any bracket and still convert respectably on an early attempt. Within every age bracket the pattern holds: the first nine attempts convert at 14% to 24%, and past the ninth that drops to 3% to 8%.

No-shows: still the biggest leak, but a smaller one

Appointments convert to written business at a healthy clip once they happen. The bigger loss is appointments that never happen. Of resolved appointments, 43.8% end in a no-show, down sharply from roughly 75% earlier in the summer. No-shows rarely recover on their own: only about one in ten ever gets rebooked.

Your best day and window are the ones you skip

Measured in each lead's own local time, there is a clear best day and a clear best window, and both are underused. Wednesday converts at 6.58%, the highest of any day, but carries noticeably less volume than the days around it. The 4 to 6pm local window converts at 5.70%. The single heaviest-worked block, Thursday and the 2 to 4pm hour, is also the weakest-converting, at 3.62% and 3.59%. The most dials are going where the odds are lowest.

Six moves, in priority order

  1. Cap how deep a lead gets redialed. Once a lead passes its ninth attempt without connecting, move it to a much slower follow-up cadence, especially on leads eight days to three months old, where redial depth is heaviest. Conversion never recovers above 0.9% past attempt nine.
  2. Push more of the week back onto fresh, first-touch leads. Protect time for leads getting their first-ever dial instead of letting the queue default to whatever is already mid-sequence. Only 10.5% of leads touched last week were a first dial.
  3. Confirm every appointment the morning of. One text or one call. 43.8% of resolved appointments still end in a no-show, and only about one in ten ever gets rebooked.
  4. Shift some volume from Thursday afternoon to Wednesday and late afternoon. Wednesday converts at 6.58% and 4 to 6pm at 5.70%, against 3.62% and 3.59% for the current heaviest day and window.
  5. Keep doing what is working on new-lead speed. First dials inside seven days jumped from 44% to 81%. Do not let it slip.
  6. Stay on the line ten seconds for a live voice. Hold a connected call at least ten seconds before ending it; keep the instant hangup for machines and IVR menus. It is free caller-reputation hygiene.

None of this asks for more dials. It asks for the same hours to be spent where they actually pay: on the attempts, the leads, and the windows that convert.

Method. All figures are from Silver Bow call data, June 17 to September 13, 2026, for a single agent's book. Conversation means a connected call of 60 seconds or more; engaged means 15 seconds or more. Appointments are identified from calendar entries linked to a lead. Caveats worth holding: platform comparisons are unadjusted for lead source, price point, or market; appointment and no-show tracking comes from status-change history that agents maintain inconsistently; attempt-number comparisons are within-lead and selected by construction, since a lead that will answer often answers early; and Saturday's window figure is likely distorted by one unusually weak day.

Dial Pacing Study

The same study, formatted as a branded PDF to save, print, or share.

Download PDF
Free

Presentation

Download the presentation to use in your team meetings

Download Slides
Free
inXfIG

See it work on your own leads.

Book a quick demo, or start dialing today.

Book a DemoGet Started